Filed under: Uncategorized | Tags: Atlanta, Chivas USA, Deep South, Detroit, Don Garber, English Premier League, German Bundesliga, Icarus, Italian Serie A, Kansas City, Major League Baseball, Major League Soccer, Minneapolis, NBA, New York City FC, NFL, NHL, North American Soccer League, Oklahoma City, Orlando, Sacramento, Spanish La Liga, Toronto FC
Major League Soccer will expand to 24 teams by 2020.
League Commissioner Don Garber made that announcement during a TV interview at halftime of his league’s all-star game in Kansas City. It comes on the heels of the addition of New York City FC for the 2015 season, which was believed to cap the number of MLS teams at 20. The goal of two dozen teams opens the door for hopefuls such as Orlando, Detroit, Atlanta, Sacramento, Oklahoma City and Minneapolis, whose representatives have been trying to woo MLS in recent months.
“As MLS enters a period of accelerated growth, the addition of new teams will allow us to expand our geographic coverage, grow our fan base and help us achieve our vision of being among the best leagues in the world by 2022,” said Garber. [July 31]
Comment: Sheer folly.
Without promotion/relegation–and there will never be promotion/relegation involving MLS–even the idea of 20 teams, let alone 24, is ridiculous.
Twenty-four teams would make MLS the world’s biggest top-flight soccer circuit. Impressive distinction. But there are reasons why leagues with pro/rel in soccer-mad countries–the Italian Serie A, Spain’s La Liga, the English Premier League, the German Bundesliga 1, the Brasileiro Serie A, etc.–limit membership to 18 or 20 clubs.
Never mind the questionable potential or track records of the possible MLS markets being discussed. Just go with the numbers. Twenty-four teams? That means that if each team magically takes turns winning an MLS Cup, the fans in an exemplary market like Portland, where the Timbers are on a 45-game home sellout streak, will have to wait more than a generation between league championships. Throw in a mini-dynasty by a team from a glamorous market like (gulp) Oklahoma City or Sacramento and the wait is even longer. Meanwhile, without promotion/relegation, troubled teams like Chivas USA and Toronto FC, with 10 or more opponents ahead of them in the conference standings, can continue to stink up the bottom of the league into perpetuity while their dwindling, hopeless fan bases look on.
So how does Garber adequately cover two enormous countries while keeping fans of losing teams engaged? He can’t continue to expand the playoffs–he already throws around playoff berths like penny candy. He should leave things, then, at an already bloated 20. And if he must restore MLS’s presence in the Deep South, he should convince the league’s biggest problem child, Chivas USA, to arrange a move to Atlanta or even Orlando (even though Florida has proven to be the black hole of pro soccer over the past three decades). Moving a team may be seen as a sign of weakness, but it’s the magic formula used for ages by Major League Baseball, the NFL, NBA and NHL whenever there’s a need to leverage a new stadium or favorable ownership change–or simply scare former fans into showing up again.
It is hoped that Garber and the MLS Board of Governors come to the realization that their league doesn’t have to be anywhere close to the NFL (32 teams), Major League Baseball (30), the NBA (30) or the NHL (30) in membership to be considered major league. Heck, the NHL was considered major league back in the mid-1960s when it had six teams; it earned that distinction by presenting a major league product. But if Garber is hell-bent on expanding to two dozen teams, he should have one last look at the U.S. soccer history books. The last soccer league here to grow to 24 was another without promotion/relegation, the North American Soccer League, in 1978. Within two years, three weak sisters went belly up, and the panic was on. Within six years, there were seven left.
Leave a Comment so far
Leave a comment